Last night I gave a presentation on my new book and explained why accounts are not to be trusted. I said that there were several new examples revealed every month of dubious accounts and today we have another one. In this case the company is AppScatter Group (APPS). This is an AIM listed company whose shares are currently suspended because of a proposed acquisition. I do not hold the shares but have been monitoring it as it operates in a sector that is of interest to me.
Today they published their interim results for the period to the end of June. To quote from it: “appScatter is a scalable B2B SaaS platform that allows paying users to distribute their apps to, and manage their apps on, multiple app stores. Additionally, the centralised platform enables app developers and publishers to manage and track performance of their own and competing apps across all of the app stores on the platform”.
Launch of the platform is behind schedule putting pressure on working capital so they have issued equity to raise £1.6 million and entered into a loan facility for £5 million on which they are paying 11% interest to cover that and the acquisition costs.
Revenue was up on the 2018 figure at £710k but the half year loss was £5.1 million. But this is the really surprising statement: “The revenue for the first six months of 2018 included accrued revenue of £576,573. This related to work carried out for corporate customers where invoicing was anticipated to occur after the reporting date. Only £38,000 of this work had been invoiced as at 31 December 2018 and given timing uncertainties under when the balance will be invoiced the accrued revenue was not recognised for the twelve months to 31 December 2019. On a consistent basis the comparable revenue figure for the first six months of 2018 would be £365,596”.
So in simple words, they recognised future revenue when there was no certainty of invoicing or when it could be billed. This is just totally imprudent accounting but the directors signed off on this and their AIM Nomad would have done so also.
This kind of sharp practice hardly inspires confidence in the future of the business. But it’s symptomatic of the lax accounting standards that have crept into public companies of late. The 2018 full year results show the CFO resigned in June 2018 and adoption of IFRS15 reduced revenue by £1 million over the prior year. The accounts were also qualified by their auditors over the valuation of their investment in Priori Data.
Unfortunately although I do not hold the company directly it is held by two of the Venture Capital Trusts I hold. I hope they make representations to the management on this issue.
Roger Lawson (Twitter: https://twitter.com/RogerWLawson )
You can “follow” this blog by clicking on the bottom right.
© Copyright. Disclaimer: Read the About page before relying on any information in this post.