Paul Scott Rants on Digital Currencies and Meme Stocks

I follow Paul Scott’s blog which generally covers small cap stocks but he also covers other stock market matters. Today he gave his views on Bitcoin, other digital currencies and “meme” stocks which are being ramped up again in the USA. He concludes that they are all simple speculations.

Today as it’s Friday his blog is free – see: https://paulypilot.substack.com/p/pauls-daily-podcast-free-friday-25

I agree totally with what he says.

His blog is usually both accurate and amusing and is highly recommended.

Roger Lawson (Twitter: https://x.com/RogerWLawson  )

You can obtain notifications of new posts in future by following me on Twitter (now “X”) – see https://x.com/RogerWLawson where new blog posts are usually mentioned.

Bitcoin Hits Record High But One Sad Person has Lost £450m in Landfill

The price of a Bitcoin has risen to over $100,000 for the first time. One sad person is suing Newport City Council for the accidental loss of a laptop hard drive deposited in a council waste dump which he alleges contained the keys to 8,000 Bitcoins.

The Council have refused to allow him to excavate the dump to retrieve the laptop and in any case they claim it is now their property.

The moral of this story is that if you are going to speculate in cryptocurrencies take great care of your security and back-ups, particularly if you have a clear-out over the Christmas holidays.

For more details see https://localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/litigation-and-enforcement/400-litigation-news/59307-court-to-hear-claim-against-council-over-ownership-of-460m-bitcoin-wallet-and-access-to-old-landfill-where-hard-drive-was-dumped-in-error

Roger Lawson (Twitter: https://twitter.com/RogerWLawson  )

You can obtain notifications of new posts in future by following me on Twitter (now “X”) – see https://x.com/RogerWLawson where new blog posts are usually mentioned.

Regulating Cryptoassets

The FCA has published a consultation document on the regulation of cryptoassets – particularly stablecoins in the first instance. It should be of interest to anyone investing in cryptocurrencies or considering doing so. To quote from it:

5.9 If a cryptoasset custodian were to fail today, the lack of a clear regulatory framework could result in uncertainty that would likely cause harm to clients through delays in the return of assets, extra costs or, worst of all, loss of their assets. Without clear regulatory standards to which cryptoasset custodians are required to adhere, cryptoassets may not be safeguarded adequately, which may lead to losses should the cryptoasset custodian enter insolvency (whether due to being treated as assets of the custodian, or through operational errors). In addition to the harm to clients, an outcome that results in uncertainty in insolvency may impact confidence in the overall regulatory regime.

5.10 This was shown in the recent failures of Celsius Network LLC and the FTX group, both of which provided cryptoasset custody services. According to its recent bankruptcy filing, Celsius had misappropriated client assets and at the time of its insolvency owed $4.7bn to customers. In the case of FTX, at least $8bn of client assets were reported to be missing. According to filings in the US bankruptcy court for Delaware on FTX Trading, FTX’s practices included ‘potential commingling of digital assets…use of an unsecured group email account as the root user to access confidential private keys and critically sensitive data…’ and ‘an absence of lasting records of decision-making.’

See https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/discussion-papers/dp23-4-regulating-cryptoassets-phase-1-stablecoins for details.

Roger Lawson (Twitter https://twitter.com/RogerWLawson  )

You can “follow” this blog by entering your email address in the box below.  You will then receive an email alerting you to new posts as they are added.

Sam Bankman-Fried Found Guilty

Yesterday Sam Bankman-Fried was found guilty of fraud in a New York Federal court over the collapse of FTX. This was the second largest crypto-currency exchange before it ceased trading with a shortfall as much as $10 billion in its accounts. Billions of client money had been lent to Alameda Research a proprietary crypto trading firm, also controlled by Bankman-Fried who could not repay it.

Bankman-Fried tried to talk his way out by giving evidence in his defence that he had consulted lawyers and they said it was OK to use client funds, allegedly.

This verdict is hardly surprising. I have been reading the book “Going Infinite”, subtitled “The rise and fall of a new tycoon”, by Michael Lewis. Clearly there were few controls in the business of FTX and people were hired with no experience – lack of financial knowledge or experience was seen as an asset!

The gullibility of the public to new get rich quick schemes is well demonstrated in the history of FTX. The UK Government has recently announced plans to regulate crypto markets which should surely be done as soon as possible.

The book mentioned is essential reading for anyone who wants to dabble in cryptocurrency and highlights some of the stupidities associated with Bankman-Fried.

Roger Lawson (Twitter https://twitter.com/RogerWLawson  )

You can “follow” this blog by entering your email address in the box below.  You will then receive an email alerting you to new posts as they are added.

Market Trends, WeWork, Cryptocurrencies, Passive Saturation

Last week was a remarkably one for my stock market portfolio. Share prices were up on almost all my holdings. This was no doubt sparked by good news from the USA – inflation seems to be under control with CPI falling to 7.7%, and the war in Ukraine is looking up as Russia withdrew from the west bank of the Dnipro River. Stalemate in the latter war is looking increasingly likely which may encourage both Russia and Ukraine to reach some accommodation.

I also get the impression that stocks were being bought back in a panic after previous sales as they fell sharply in previous months. This particularly affected less liquid small cap and AIM stocks.

But this is surely only temporary relief from the gloomy economic prognostications. Interest rates in the UK still need to rise further as inflation is still high and real interest rates still negative. Political stability may help over the next few months but it looks like we are all going to be significantly poorer from aggressive tax rises. This will not help the UK economy one bit.

I watched an interesting TV documentary on WeWork yesterday. WeWork was essentially a company that rented out office desk space, i.e. it was a property company but ended up being valued as a high flying technology business valued at a peak $47 billion before it crashed. Led by Adam Neumann as CEO in a messianic style it developed into a cult which became further and further detached from reality. As profits were non-existent they redefined the word profit.

It’s a great example of how investors can be suckered into backing dubious companies led by glib promoters simply due to FOMO (fear of missing out). There is a good book on this subject entitled “The Cult of We: WeWork and the Great Start-Up Delusion” which I have ordered and may review at a later date.

Cryptocurrency exchange FTX became bankrupt last week. At the end it looked like a typical “run on a bank” as folks rushed to take their money out. FTX reportedly had less than $1bn in easily sellable assets against $9bn in liabilities before it went bankrupt. This has also affected other cryptocurrencies as traders take their money off the table.

Can cryptocurrencies survive? Only if backed by the state I would suggest. I am reading an interesting book – the Travels of Marco Polo which covers his time spent in the Mongol empire including China circa 1300. It describes how paper money was widely accepted in the Mongol empire which covered most of Asia at the time. But it was backed by gold or silver for which it could be exchanged. One advantage of their paper money was if you wanted a lower denomination note you could simply cut up a larger one. Paper currencies do rely on public confidence which is why state backing is so essential and also confidence that holdings are not going to be devalued by excessive printing of more money. Cryptocurrencies have tackled this issue in more than one way including the need for large power consumption to create new coins. But the whole structure still seems unsound to me.

An interesting article in the Investors Chronicle this week covered the subject of passive investing under the headline “Passive Saturation”. There has been concern expressed for some time that a high proportion of the stock market is held by index tracking funds that simply follow the herd. This might magnify trends and not relate to the reality of fundamentals in the companies they buy and sell. This was previously not thought to be a problem because the “passive percentage” of the market was estimated to be only 15%. But a new academic report suggests the real figure is more like 38%.

A very high passive percentage means that stock pickers can do well, and better than the indices as they ignore trends and look at the fundamental merits of companies. I prefer actively managed funds even if you do pay more for them in charges. Funds that rely solely on momentum may have done well historically but they are likely to exaggerate trends both up and down and the higher the percentage of the market held by passive funds, the more dangerous this becomes.

Roger Lawson (Twitter: https://twitter.com/RogerWLawson  )

You can “follow” this blog by entering your email address below. You will then receive an email alerting you to new posts as they are added.

Voting at BHP and Bioventix, and Cryptocurrency Rout

The results of the Annual General Meeting of BHP Group (BHP) have been announced. The most significant item was the rejection of an amendment to the constitution by 90% of voters. This was a resolution requisitioned by Members and would have enabled shareholders to dictate operational policies on such matters as environmental issues to the directors. It was rightly rejected as removing powers from directors to manage the company in the best interests of the company is unwise.

You can read the speeches given at the AGM here: https://www.londonstockexchange.com/news-article/BHP/bhp-group-2022-agm-speeches-and-presentation/15709454 . There is a big focus on changing the culture of the organisation.

I also received the Annual Report and a proxy voting form for the AGM of AIM listed Bioventix (BVXP) today. Thankfully their share registrar, Share Registrars Ltd, have now implemented a simple and easy to use electronic proxy voting system.

I only voted against the share buy-back resolution as I can see no good reason to use surplus cash in that way rather than paying a special dividend. Share buy-backs are rarely justified and depend on the directors’ view of the value of shares which is often wrong.

I am glad to see that the cryptocurrency markets are suffering a severe bout of financial indigestion with exchange FTX in financial difficulties and Bitcoin prices back down to where they were in 2020. Mining company Argo Blockchain (ARB) listed on AIM also appears to be in difficulty.

I’ll repeat what I said in January 2021 on why I won’t be investing in Bitcoins: “There is no intrinsic value in a Bitcoin. With company shares the intrinsic value may be somewhat uncertain and share prices subject to the emotions of investors but there is at least a way to determine the value by looking at the discounted cash flows generated by a company. The future cash flows help you to determine the current value. But with cryptocurrencies there are no associated cash flows. No dividends paid out and no profits generated directly from the assets as with company shares.

If you buy cryptocurrencies you are simply buying a “pig in a poke”.

Roger Lawson

You can “follow” this blog by entering your email address below. You will then receive an email alerting you to new posts as they are added.

Bitcoin Mania

Two recent events tell me that the mania for Bitcoins and other digital currencies is alive and well, while I am still stuck in the dark ages and prefer to invest in companies that produce something.

On the way home by train from central London today sat next to me were two young ladies obviously returning from doing some Christmas shopping in the West End. They were discussing what to give to young children for xmas. One mentioned that they knew kids who had been given Bitcoins as an xmas present.

Secondly when I was in my local bank last week, someone was in there to transfer cash to a foreign based coin exchange or broker. The counter clerk queried it but let it go through.

The FCA banned the sale of crypto-derivatives to retail customers in October 2020 and later issued a warning to retail investors of the risks associated with other cryptoasset-related investments, stating that those who choose to invest should be prepared to lose the full amount of their investment. But are they really doing enough to educate the general public about the risks associated with such assets? I don’t think so.

 But giving Bitcoins to young children may of course be very educational. They might learn that when something is valued not on any intrinsic merit or future income potential but on what speculators are willing to pay for it then it’s going to be a very volatile asset.   

Roger Lawson (Twitter: https://twitter.com/RogerWLawson  )

You can “follow” this blog by clicking on the bottom right in most browsers or by using the Contact page to send us a message requesting. You will then receive an email alerting you to new posts as they are added.